Mail.png

Media Statement: HSF Admitted as Amicus Curiae in Mfalapitsa v The State and Rorich.

Media Statement: HSF Admitted as Amicus Curiae in Mfalapitsa v The State and Rorich.

On 5 November 2026 and after filing our application on 29 September 2026, the Helen Suzman Foundation (HSF) was admitted as amicus curiae in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) matter of Mfalapitsa v The State and Rosich (312/2026 & 313/2026). This follows the SCA’s earlier order on 28 May 2026 admitting HSF as amicus curiae in the related appeal brought by Mr. Mfalapitsa’s co-accused, Rorich v The State and Mfalapitsa (1173/2025).

Both appeals arise from the High Court judgement in S v Ephraim and Others (SS70/2021) [2025], concerning the 1982 deaths of the COSAS 4. Mr. Mfalapitsa and Mr. Rorich were indicted under section 232 of the Constitution on three counts of the crime against humanity of murder and one count of the crime against humanity of apartheid.

In the High Court, the accused argued that the State’s right to institute a prosecution had prescribed in terms of section 18 of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977, given that more than twenty years had elapsed since the alleged offences were committed. The Court dismissed both objections, holding that crimes against humanity do not prescribe and may be prosecuted under customary international law as it is incorporated into South African law through section 232 of the Constitution.

In the Mfalapitsa Appeal, HSF will argue that crimes against humanity, including apartheid, are peremptory norms (jus cogens) under international law not subject to prescription under section 18 of the Criminal Procedure Act. HSF will further submit that South Africa has a constitutional and international duty to prosecute these offences rather than serve as a haven for alleged perpetrators.

The outcome of both appeals holds important implications for accountability, the rule of law, and South Africa’s ability to prosecute crimes against humanity domestically.

Read our papers here.